Introductory activities
Here on Earth is a complex argument about having hope for the future. It is much longer than many arguments students will have read in the past and involves quite lengthy explanations of scientific concepts and processes. Moreover, it marshals evidence from a range of disciplines and sources in order to convince the reader. As such, many students will probably need careful preparation for reading, including:
- tapping into their own values and beliefs about the future;
- background knowledge about some of the key figures mentioned in the book;
- an awareness of how the book is structured, as well as the sort of challenges they might face reading this text and how they can be confronted.
These three areas are the focus of the activities below. However, they will also be useful to help teachers identify additional preparation that some or all students may require. It should be noted that an assumption has been made that teachers would prepare students for vocabulary as a standard practice. Therefore, no activities of that type are included here, although they may be essential.
1. Visions of the future
Ask students to write a description of the world in which, ideally, they hope or expect to live in the future. Use the visualisation process (PDF, 100KB) to encourage rich responses. This activity works best if you have a large, carpeted space available and writing materials are out and ready for Step 6.
In groups, students should now reflect on their responses.
- What did the responses have in common? In what ways were they different?
- Were the futures envisaged mainly positive or negative?
- What might have influenced their responses? Students should relate specific examples of the future that they have seen depicted or read about in newspapers, magazines, books, television shows, on the Internet and in films. Discuss whether these depictions are mainly positive or negative and reasons why. For example, stories about danger and despair ‘sell’ better; science fiction (especially in popular films) usually taps into contemporary fears.
At this point, students should:
- be (re)introduced to the terms utopia and dystopia;
- read an article about the way science fiction reflects the earthly fears of each generation.
What are the possible consequences (strengths and limitations) of believing too strongly in either a negative OR positive view of the future?
2. Tuning in (background and frontloading)
Given that this is quite a complex non-fiction text, provision of background information and other frontloading will likely be essential for most students. These could include the following.
Working in groups, students study the cover (front and back), scan the table of contents and flick through the images in the centre of the book. On the basis of their observations, students can make predictions:
- Genre and purpose: What type of writing does this appear to be? Why might it have been written? Why might I read it? Given the genre, how do I expect this book to be structured?
- Subject matter: What do I think the book will be about?
- Roles and relationships: Who is Tim Flannery? What do I know about him? What can I expect of him? Who does the audience appear to be?
- Mode and medium: Will this book rely on words alone to communicate its message?
- Language: Given my other predictions, what can I expect of the language used? What might this mean for the way I read the book and strategies I might need to employ?
Answers to these questions can guide teachers in other preparation (beyond that listed here) that might be be necessary.
It is recommended that students view an interview between Tim Flannery and Australian science journalist Robyn Williams and/or academic Anne Summers. Depending on the skills and prior learning of the students, the teacher may need to preview each chapter, conducting a guided reading, drawing students’ attention to the structure (including relationship of the chapter to the overall argument), key aspects of language, important points raised, and any other note-worthy elements. Finally, students might benefit from a video of Flannery summarising his case. A more detailed overview of the book can be obtained by scanning the comprehensive “Table of Contents” that is reminiscent of the type found in early books (including Voyage of the Beagle and On the Origin of Species by Charles Darwin).
3. Background to historical and contemporary figures
Students will imagine that they work for a company that creates content for third-party websites. Text Publishing has commissioned them to produce materials for a website to support Tim Flannery’s Here on Earth. In particular, the publishers want short videos or presentations to provide background on a number of scientists who feature in the book:
- Charles Darwin
- Alfred Russell Wallace
- James Lovelock
- Peter Ward
- Richard Dawkins
- Bill Hamilton
- Rachel Carson
If desired, students could also research these significant mythological figures:
- Medea
- Gaia
Videos could be produced using software such as iMovie or VideoScribe, and presentations created using Prezi and PowerPoint.
Drawing on information from reliable sources, the video/presentation needs to include:
- brief, relevant biographical information;
- for Darwin and Wallace, reference to the relationship between them;
- a summary and overall evaluation of their key contributions to science.
Students should consider the role of words, images and sound in their video/presentation. When completed, students should have the opportunity to view each others’ presentations and ask questions.
(ACEEN021) (ACEEN022) (ACEEN024) (ACEEN026) (ACEEN028) (ACEEN029) (ACEEN031) (ACEEN033) (ACEEN036) (ACEEN040)
Personal response on reading the text
1. Summarising and reflecting on the book
The argument developed by Flannery is complex and students will need to read actively and attentively by:
- identifying key messages;
- selecting important, illustrative quotations;
- making connections (within and beyond the text, to their own experiences and understandings, and the world beyond the text);
- making comments and drawing conclusions;
- and asking probing, critical questions.
The Graphic Overview (PDF, 143KB) will assist them to do this. Teachers will need to undertake modelling and guided practice to ensure students complete the overview effectively.
After students have completed reading a ‘chunk’ of Here on Earth (e.g. a chapter or section), it is recommended that students share and discuss their Graphic Overviews in small groups (or Literature Circles). Continue doing this until the whole book has been read and discussed.
2. Immediate response (Paper Ball Throwing)
Once students are finished, they share their immediate response: Were you persuaded by Flannery’s argument? Why or why not? What was the big message you took away from Here on Earth? These questions can be displayed on a whiteboard or screen and will ensure that students move beyond simple like/dislike responses. To ensure honest answers and a degree of privacy, use the ‘Paper Ball Throwing’ strategy (PDF, 107KB). This will also ensure that students are exposed to a range of other views in the class.
After a few rounds of paper ball throwing, the teacher should collect the written responses and form students into groups of three. Each group will be given three, randomly assigned slips. Using the retrieval chart (PDF, 99KB), students working in groups sort and categorise the responses. After appropriate time, each group joins with one other group of three and combines their findings into one table. Continue with this process until there is one, whole-class table summarising and classifying all responses. Discuss:
- Do any patterns emerge?
- How did most students in the class respond to the arguments in Here on Earth? Is there unanimity in response?
- What were the most common reasons given for being persuaded or not?
- Why might different people in the class respond differently (or similarly)?
Use this information as a starting point for detailed, close reading and analysis.
Outline of key elements of the text
Here on Earth is an extended argument that there is hope for the future of humans here on Earth. However, Flannery argues that, along with hope, climate ‘catastrophe can only be avoided with goodwill and understanding’. Thus, this is not a book about science, but rather a book that draws on science, history and even literature for rhetorical purposes. It will be of interest for exploring the:
- ways science can be used and read;
- skilful manipulation of persuasive strategies and devices, for example via ethos, logos and pathos;
- reasons responses to a text might vary;
- status of non-fiction texts in relation to fiction.
Synthesising activity
If there is time, students could be asked to create and screen a book trailer for Here on Earth in order to summarise and synthesise their initial reaction to the book. To make the task more challenging, the intended audience could be people whose response to the book might be different from their own (see the Paper Ball Throwing activity). This will also encourage students to recall persuasive devices and strategies before moving on to a close reading of the text. If a quicker activity is required, ask students to write a blog-style entry summarising and synthesising their reactions. The blog should be one devoted to books and literature.
(ACEEN024) (ACEEN026) (ACEEN028) (ACEEN031) (ACEEN032) (ACEEN033) (ACEEN036) (ACEEN040)